blog

Captain in prison, shipowner with a limit – Dark Stories #24

In March 2025, the feeder ship Solong rammed into the anchored tanker Stena Immaculate. The captain was sentenced to 6 years in prison, yet the court still allowed the shipowner to limit their liability. We explain why a criminal conviction does not mean compensation for the cargo.

On March 10, 2025, the feeder container ship Solong, operating the Samskip Grangemouth–Rotterdam service, struck the anchored tanker Stena Immaculate at a speed of approximately 16 knots. The tanker was carrying jet fuel for the U.S. military. A sailor died, both ships caught fire, and a large portion of the containers on board the Solong were lost. In 2026, British courts issued two rulings that, at first glance, seem contradictory. The captain was sent to prison for gross negligence, yet the shipowner is still permitted to limit their liability to the statutory cap. What does this story tell Polish exporters and importers whose containers travel daily on feeder ships across the North Sea?

The Scene: 16 knots toward an anchored tanker

It is March 10, 2025. The North Sea, off the coast of England.

The Stena Immaculate is at anchor. It is a U.S.-flagged tanker loaded with jet fuel for the U.S. military. A ship at anchor does not move, so from the perspective of maritime collision prevention regulations, other vessels must navigate around it.

The Solong is sailing from Grangemouth, Scotland, to Rotterdam. It is a typical feeder ship, like hundreds of others operating in European short-sea shipping. On board, it carries containers from various shippers, including, presumably, cargo intended to be transferred to larger vessels in Rotterdam or moved further by rail and truck.

The Solong does not slow down or change course. At a speed of about 16 knots, it strikes the side of the tanker. Jet fuel leaks and ignites. Fire engulfs both ships. A crew member, Mark Angelo Pernia from the Philippines, went missing on the Solong. His body was never recovered.

A large portion of the containers on board the Solong are either burned or fit only for disposal. Rescuers move in. For the cargo owners, a second, much longer story begins then.

Criminal verdict: six years for gross negligence

The case seems straightforward. A moving ship strikes an anchored ship, and a criminal court determines the captain is at fault. On February 5, 2026, the captain of the Solong is sentenced to 6 years in prison for manslaughter by gross negligence (gross negligence manslaughter). Under English law, this is a serious charge. It requires proving that the breach of duty was so egregious that it warrants criminal, rather than just civil, liability.

For many cargo owners, the case is closed at this point. There is guilt, there is a verdict, so someone will pay in full for the burned containers.

Until May 22, 2026.

Admiralty Court: the captain's fault is not the shipowner's fault

In the case of MS "Solong" v Samskip Multimodal BV [2026] EWHC 1211 (Admlty) The owner of the Solong applied to the Admiralty Court for a declaration that they could limit their liability for the consequences of a collision. The basis for this is the Convention on Limitation of Liability for Maritime Claims (LLMC) of 1976. According to source materials, the case was heard by the same judge who had previously presided over the criminal proceedings.

The court granted the shipowner the right to limitation. The reasoning is based on a legal construct that surprises many shippers. The LLMC Convention allows a shipowner to be deprived of the right to limit liability only if the damage resulted from their personal act or omission, committed with the intent to cause such loss, or recklessly and with knowledge that such loss would probably result. Gross negligence on the part of the captain, even if confirmed by a criminal conviction, does not constitute the personal fault of the shipowner.

In practice, this means that the shipowner's liability for claims related to a collision is capped at the limitation fund. The amount of this fund depends on the vessel's tonnage, not the value of the destroyed property. All creditors seeking compensation for property damage—the tanker owner, cargo owners, and parties affected by pollution—are satisfied from this same fund. Everyone receives a proportional share.

Three barriers for the cargo owner

The story of the Solong clearly illustrates why a criminal conviction against a captain changes so little for a container owner. Between the burned cargo and full compensation stand three independent barriers.

First barrier: navigational error. If the carriage is performed under a bill of lading subject to the Hague-Visby Rules, the carrier is not liable for damage resulting from the act, neglect, or default of the master or crew in the navigation or management of the ship. A collision caused by poor ship handling is a classic example of a navigational error. The more clearly a court attributes fault to the captain, the more strongly the carrier can rely on this exemption.

Second barrier: global limitation. Even if a cargo owner sues the shipowner outside of the contract of carriage, they will encounter the LLMC limit. The ruling of May 22, 2026, shows how high the bar is set for breaking this limit. It is not enough to prove that something scandalous happened on the ship. One must demonstrate the personal fault of the shipowner themselves, which in practice means their management.

Third barrier: salvage security. Salvors who extinguish a fire and tow a wreck are entitled to remuneration. The cargo that was successfully saved is also liable for this remuneration. Before a container owner can collect what remains of their goods, they usually must post security for salvage claims. They pay, therefore, before they even begin to assert their rights, even if they were not at fault in any way.

A note for the Polish exporter

The mechanism from the North Sea applies to every Polish company whose container is transported by a feeder vessel, whether from Gdynia or Gdańsk to Rotterdam, Hamburg, or Bremerhaven, or in the opposite direction.

  • The Hague-Visby Rules protect the carrier from the captain's error. The exemption for errors in navigation or management of the ship applies regardless of how serious that error was. The Polish Maritime Code provides for an analogous solution. Even in the best-case scenario, the carrier's liability is capped by a limit per package or per kilogram of cargo.
  • A criminal conviction does not replace civil proceedings. The conviction of a captain does not determine the liability of the shipowner or the contractual carrier toward the cargo. These are two different legal orders with different criteria.
  • The LLMC limit is shared among all injured parties. In the event of a collision with a tanker, the owner of the other vessel, insurers, the cargo owners of both ships, and those harmed by pollution all reach for the fund. The share of an individual shipper may turn out to be symbolic.
  • Incoterms decide whose problem it is. With FOB, FCA, CFR, or CPT, risk transfers to the buyer no later than at the port of loading. While the seller must purchase insurance under CIF and CIP, damage in transit is borne by the buyer as the insured party. With DAP, DPU, and DDP, the exporter bears the risk until the destination.
  • A cargo policy is the only real protection. Insurance under Institute Cargo Clauses (A) covers damages resulting from collisions and fires. It also standardly covers salvage costs attributable to the cargo. It is crucial that the insurer issues a salvage guarantee, without which the cargo will not be released.

Practical takeaway: Check the Incoterms under which you buy and sell, and clearly establish who is insuring the cargo during the feeder stage. Ensure that your cargo policy covers salvage costs and the obligation to issue a guarantee. After an incident, report the claim to your insurer immediately and do not wait for the outcome of criminal proceedings, as claim deadlines run independently of them.

The moral

In episode #4, we wrote about the fire on the MSC Flaminia, and in episode #6, about how a container alone does not protect you from the bill for someone else's disaster. The story of the Solong adds another paradox to this list. A court may find that the captain was so much at fault that he ends up in prison. Even so, the same legal mechanism that has regulated shipping for decades protects the shipowner and carrier from the full bill.

This is not a loophole in the system, but its design. Maritime law intentionally distributes risk so that cargo insures itself. Those who do not know this discover it at the worst possible moment: when their container is sitting on a charred wreck and the salvor is waiting for a guarantee.

The captain's guilt may land him in prison, but only a policy will save your cargo.

Sources

  • MS "Solong" v Samskip Multimodal BV [2026] EWHC 1211 (Admlty), High Court of Justice, Admiralty Court, judgment of May 22, 2026.

Factual and legal status as of November 2026.

Our previous publications from the "Dark Stories" series

‍

Want to better plan your supply chain?
Our experts will help you select a transport solution tailored to your destination, cargo type, and operational priorities. Call us at  +48 720 803 853 or email us directly at biuro@insphera.pl.